EverQuote (EVER)

Generated: October 31, 2026

Red Dot

Statistics

Metric	Value
Last Close	$28.80
Blended Price Target	29.75
Blended Margin of Safety	3.3% Fairly Valued
Rule of 40 (Next)	52.6%
Rule of 40 (Current)	60.4%
FCF-ROIC	42.4%
Sales Growth Next Year	10.3%
Sales Growth Current Year	18.0%
Sales 3-Year Avg	35.5%
Industry	Internet Content & Information

Analysis

EverQuote is a high-quality but inherently variable digital marketplace rather than a predictable subscription software business. Its recent performance shows strong demand for digitally sourced insurance customers, with second-quarter 2026 revenue up 25% year over year and management describing carrier demand as healthy.^[10] The growth outlook is supported by expansion beyond auto insurance, better matching technology, and increased insurer participation, but it remains exposed to advertising economics and carrier budgets.

The business has a useful data and distribution advantage, though its moat is moderate rather than unassailable. EverQuote benefits from accumulated consumer-intent data, insurer relationships, and traffic-optimization capabilities, but customers can redirect marketing budgets and competing lead channels remain available. Leadership appears operationally capable, and the balance sheet provides flexibility, but the company’s quality depends on maintaining marketplace liquidity and disciplined customer acquisition more than on recurring contracts.

What the Company Does

EverQuote operates a digital marketplace that connects consumers seeking insurance with insurance carriers and other providers. It attracts shoppers through online marketing, gathers information about their needs, and uses technology to match them with insurers. Revenue is primarily generated when carriers purchase consumer leads, inquiries, or other performance-based marketing opportunities.

The business is concentrated in property and casualty insurance, especially auto, with a growing home and renters offering. In the second quarter of 2026, auto generated approximately 88% of revenue and home and renters approximately 12%, based on reported revenue of $172.1 million and $23.0 million, respectively.^[10]

Revenue Recurrence & Predictability

EverQuote’s revenue is primarily transactional and performance-based rather than subscription-based or contractually recurring. Insurers generally pay for leads, consumer interactions, or marketing outcomes, so revenue depends on traffic volume, consumer conversion, carrier demand, pricing, and the mix of insurance products.

That structure makes revenue less predictable than software revenue with annual contracts. Repeat insurer relationships and ongoing consumer demand provide some continuity, but spending can change quickly when carriers adjust underwriting capacity, customer-acquisition budgets, or geographic priorities. Recent disclosures do not provide a precise percentage of recurring revenue, and the business should therefore be viewed as repeatable but not highly predictable.

Revenue Growth Durability

EverQuote can likely sustain above-market growth while it expands its share of digital insurance distribution and develops additional insurance verticals. Auto remains the core opportunity, while home and renters offer a smaller base for cross-selling and diversification. The company also benefits when insurers increase digital marketing budgets and seek measurable customer-acquisition channels.

The main constraint is that growth is tied to insurer economics rather than only consumer demand. Competition for online traffic, rising advertising costs, changes in search and social-platform algorithms, and periods when carriers restrict new business could slow expansion. The second-quarter 2026 outlook still called for revenue of $198 million to $208 million in the following quarter, indicating continued near-term momentum, but not eliminating the model’s cyclicality.^[10]

Economic Moat

EverQuote’s advantages come from accumulated data, marketplace scale, and the ability to optimize matching between consumer intent and insurer demand. More traffic and insurer participation can improve targeting, conversion, and monetization, creating a marketplace effect. Its technology and historical performance data may also help allocate marketing spending more efficiently than less specialized channels.

The moat is meaningful but not strongly protected by switching costs. Insurers can shift budgets among lead generators, comparison sites, search advertising, agencies, and direct channels. EverQuote’s advantage can narrow if platforms capture more consumer intent, if competitors replicate its optimization tools, or if traffic-acquisition costs rise faster than monetization. The moat appears to be strengthening through scale and diversification, but it remains dependent on execution and external platforms.

Management & Leadership

EverQuote is led by CEO Jayme Mendal, who has been associated with the company’s executive leadership for several years. The company is not best characterized as founder-led in the traditional sense, although director and significant shareholder David Blundin remains an important insider presence. Publicly available recent disclosures identify substantial insider ownership, but the available secondary ownership data should be treated cautiously because it is not an official company financial disclosure.^[5]

Management’s recent record includes expanding home and renters insurance while maintaining strong auto growth and profitability. The company ended the second quarter of 2026 with $192.3 million of cash and no debt, and reported $24.3 million of operating cash flow.^[10] Those figures suggest financial flexibility, though the most important capital-allocation test remains whether management can reinvest without sacrificing marketplace efficiency.

Key Risks

The central risk is insurer spending volatility. Carriers may reduce marketing budgets when underwriting losses rise, capacity tightens, regulatory conditions change, or customer-acquisition economics deteriorate. Because EverQuote’s revenue is transaction-driven, these decisions can affect results faster than they would in a contracted business.

The company also depends on digital traffic sources and technology platforms it does not control. Changes to search rankings, advertising auctions, privacy rules, mobile tracking, or social-platform policies could raise acquisition costs or reduce consumer volume. Cybersecurity failures, inaccurate matching, or poor lead quality could damage both conversion rates and insurer relationships.

Competitive and regulatory risks are substantial. Insurers can develop direct channels, while other marketplaces and lead providers compete for the same consumers and budgets. Insurance advertising and lead-generation practices may face stricter disclosure, consent, privacy, or state-level regulation. Concentration in auto insurance also leaves the business exposed to changes in carrier appetite and the broader health of the auto-insurance market.

Sources

Featured in GreenDot Stocks Analysis

GreenDot Stocks Screen Update — Week of November 7, 2026 November 7, 2026
GreenDot Stocks Screen Update — Week of October 31, 2026 October 31, 2026
GreenDot Stocks Screen Update — Week of October 24, 2026 October 24, 2026
GreenDot Stocks Screen Update — Week of October 17, 2026 October 17, 2026
GreenDot Stocks Screen Update — Week of October 10, 2026 October 10, 2026